EAST WEST
Dwight Howard Andrew Bynum
LeBron James Blake Griffin
Carmelo Anthony Kevin Durant
Dwyane Wade Kobe Bryant
Derrick Rose Chris Paul
Paul Pierce Dirk Nowitzki
Chris Bosh Steve Nash
Luol Deng LaMarcus Aldridge
Roy Hibbert Marc Gasol
Andre Iguodala Kevin Love
Joe Johnson Tony Parker
Deron Williams Russell Westbrook
Missed the cut
Josh Smith Monta Ellis
Rajon Rondo Kyle Lowry
Brandon Jennings Rudy Gay
Greg Monroe Paul Millsap
Andrea Bargnani Pau Gasol
Sub the Snubs
Josh Smith vs Roy Hibbert
Josh Smith is an exciting player whose game is tailor-fit for the
all-star game. Not only is his offensive game high-flying, he also
plays defense with 1.5 steals and 2 blocks per game. Since Al Horford
went down, the Hawks are 9-3 thanks to the play of J-Smoove and he would
make a great all-star. Though Hibbert has had a breakthrough year with
13.6 points and 9.9 rebounds he still averages fewer steals (0.4) and
blocks (1.4) than Smith. Hibbert will be considered for most improved
player of the year, but he's at the ASG because of his size, 7'2", and
the need for a backup centre. Greg Monroe could have been considered for
backup centre, but the Pistons are 8-21 and the Pacers are 17-10. Winning counts.
Monta Ellis vs Tony Parker
Monta has been left off
the all-star team for years now. A scoring point guard gets no love in
the NBA. Russell Westbrook gets the all-star nod because he plays on the
Thunder, the NBA's best young team, but the numbers between Ellis and
Westbrook are almost identical. Ellis leads Parker in almost every
statistical category except assists (Parker 7.7, Ellis 6.1) and field
goal percentage. The Spurs are 19-9 mostly without Manu and the Warriors
are 10-14 mostly without Curry, causing both Parker and Ellis to stand
up. The argument could be made that Ellis is the more talented player, but winning counts.
Pau Gasol vs Marc Gasol
Marc's election to the all-star team is an attempt to get a
Grizzlies representative in Orlando, though Pau has been statistically
better than Marc this season. Marc has earned this spot by filling the
gap in the Memphis frontcourt caused by Zach Randolph's partial MCL tear.
Memphis is 14-14, while Los Angeles is 16-12. Pau is averaging 16.7
points, 10.5 rebounds, and 3.0 assists while Marc is averaging 15.0,
10.0 and 2.8, but Marc has a slight edge in blocks and steals with 2.2 and 1.1 compared to Pau's 1.2 and
0.5. Marc has been able to amass these stats without sharing the
frontcourt, while Pau's numbers are certainly diminished by the presence
of all-star starting centre Andrew Bynum on the Lakers. Pau's numbers
rival Bynum's (who shoots just 58% from the line compared to Pau's 80%, I
might add) but only one is an all-star. Pau deserved a spot, but was
the odd man out.
Paul Millsap vs Dirk Nowitzki
I don't know how
everybody thought that the coaches wouldn't select last years' Finals
MVP tot eh all-star game. Though Dirk has had a tough time hitting his
stride this season, his star status and reigning NBA champion status
should earn him an automatic bid even though Dirk himself admitted he
wasn't worthy of a selection based on numbers and team wins. Paul
Millsap's inspired play this season made many people think he'd earn an
all-star selection, but he lost out to the 'lifetime achievement' vote.
Dallas is 17-11 and has improved throughout the year while the Utah Jazz
are 14-12. Millsap averages 16.3 points, 9.6 rebounds and 2.1 assists,
while Dirk averages 18.3, 6.2 and 2.3. The most telling stat is that
Millsap is shooting 0.308 from three, while Dirk is shooting just 0.239
from deep this season. Utah fans want a player in the all-star game, but
Dirk's resume and recent achievements more than give him the benefit of
the doubt.
In the end it's a tough call. Team records sometimes matter, and
sometimes don't. Personal statistical measures often matter, and
sometimes they don't. And sometimes the all-stars selected are just the
biggest stars in the NBA regardless of record or statistics; their image
and clout speak for themselves. It's not a pretty, or even necessary
process, and as unscientific as it is, it's all for fun anyways.
To the guys that made it - congrats. Don't go and get a big head.
To the guys that didn't - it's just an all-star game. Prove you matter when it really counts.